Don Mattingly
Baseball (Sports Trading Card) • Post Cereal 1991 Collector Series
Card Type
Base Card / First Baseman
Set & Number
Post Cereal 1991 Collector Series - 13 of 30
Rarity
Common (Food Promo)
Edition & Language
Standard Cereal Box Release • English
Condition & Value Assessment
Condition Grade
Moderately Played (MP)
Estimated Market Value
Raw: $0.50 - $2.00; Graded (PSA 10): $25.00 - $40.00
Recent Sales
Recent raw sales for this card generally range from $0.99 to $3.00 depending on shipping. Higher-grade slabbed versions rarely exceed $50.
Condition Details
Significant surface scratching and indentation across the center image; considerable edge wear and corner blunting, particularly on the bottom right; centering is slightly heavy to the right.
Grading Recommendation
Not recommended for grading. The visible surface damage and edge wear would likely result in a grade of PSA 4 or 5, which cost more to process than the final market value of the card.
Card Description
Don Mattingly, New York Yankees, First Baseman. Features an action shot of Mattingly batting in his Yankees pinstripe uniform. Reverse typically includes career statistics and a short bio.
Notable Features
This card was originally part of a cereal box panel and had to be cut out, which often affects the edge consistency compared to standard factory-cut packs.
Authentication Notes
Authentic 1991 Post Cereal release. The print quality, card stock texture, and MLB/Post logos align with mid-90s food-issue promotional production standards.
Scanned: 2026-07-11T04:53:05.587831